Now, row brews over Joseph being asked to take oath last – Times of India

NEW DELHI: A community of Supreme Court judges has determined to lodge a shriek with Chief Justice of India Dipak Misra on Monday on the ‘seniority’ Justice Okay M Joseph will experience in the SC in the context of the converse of oath-taking that can also just sort him the juniormost of three new judges to be sworn in on Tuesday.

The shriek comes despite the apex judiciary succeeding in getting the Centre to just fetch the collegium’s reiteration of its advice that Justice Joseph, who became Uttarakhand chief justice, be appointed as a Supreme Court seize.
The community of judges has determined to meet the CJI to rely on of him to situation loyal the converse of oath-taking where Justice Indira Banerjee will hang oath first adopted by Justices Vineet Saran and Joseph. This would maybe suggest Justice Banerjee would maybe maybe be the seniormost, leaving Justice Joseph the juniormost amongst the three.
The community believes Justice Joseph can also just peaceful hang oath first as his title became suggested months sooner than the varied two. The SC collegium had suggested Justice Joseph’s title along with senior advocate Indu Malhotra on January 10. While the Centre authorized the advice for Malhotra, it returned Justice Joseph’s title on April 30 for reconsideration on the grounds that he lacked requisite seniority.
At that point, Justice Joseph’s title figured at 42 on the all-India judges’ seniority checklist.After Justice Malhotra took oath as an SC seize, the collegium on Will also just 10 in-thought determined to reiterate Justice Joseph’s title.
Justice Joseph has turn into an ego field for govt : Judges
Justice Okay M Joseph’s title became sent to the authorities along with the names of Justices Banerjee and Saran on July sixteen. The Centre authorized the advice nonetheless performed a “trick” by specifying the converse of taking oath in converse to sort Justice Joseph the juniormost of the three even supposing his title became suggested eight months sooner than the varied two, sources told TOI.
The community of judges believes that Justice Joseph’s title has turn into an “ego field” with the BJP-led NDA authorities. Though the Centre had cited lack of seniority, it became widely talked about that the Centre’s switch became vengeful as Justice Joseph as Uttarakhand HC CJ had quashed imposition of President’s rule in the recount in April 2016 ensuing in restoration of the Congress-led Harish Rawat authorities.
The judges in fact feel the Centre has sought to relegate Justice Joseph to the 0.33 slot in oath taking as it would also now not quit his appointment as a seize of the apex court docket. They in fact feel that since now not one among the three new judges who will hang oath on Tuesday will plug on to turn into CJI, there became no cause to relegate Justice Joseph to the juniormost space except to make a choice a rating with the judiciary for its insistence on Justice Joseph’s elevation.
If greater than one seize takes oath on a single day, then traditionally the President (study the authorities) decides the converse by which they hang oath. Justice Dipak Misra became CJI because of he took oath sooner than Justice J Chelameswar on October 10, 2011. While Justice Misra became appointed as an HC seize one and a half years sooner than Justice Chelameswar, the latter became HC CJ outdated to Justice Misra. The department of justice counts seniority from the day a individual is appointed as an HC seize and now not from the day a individual becomes CJ of an HC.
Justice Joseph became an HC seize on October 14, 2004, HC CJ on July 31, 2014, and will retire on June sixteen, 2023.